Ultimate Allergy-Friendly Chicken Salad Sandwich: Gluten-Free, Dairy-Free, & Egg-Free Recipe

Discover how to recreate the classic, craveable chicken salad sandwich without gluten, dairy, or eggs. This truly delicious recipe is packed with incredible texture and flavor from sunflower seeds, red onion, celery, and sweet grapes, making it a crowd-pleaser for everyone, even those without dietary restrictions. Prepare to enjoy a beloved favorite once again!

This post contains affiliate links.

Why This Allergy-Friendly Chicken Salad Sandwich Is a Must-Try

Chicken salad sandwiches have always held a special place in my heart. They were a staple throughout my childhood, gracing my lunchbox, appearing at countless bridal and baby showers, and serving as an effortless, no-cook dinner solution on busy evenings. However, even before navigating the complexities of food allergies, I often found classic chicken salad recipes to be a bit underwhelming. They sometimes lacked a certain zest or crunch, leaving me wishing for more.

Despite not having food allergies myself, I’ve embraced creating delicious, allergy-friendly meals for my son. This particular chicken salad recipe has become a genuine highlight in our dinner rotation. It’s not just a compromise; it’s genuinely fantastic, incredibly easy to prepare, and a dish I eagerly anticipate every time. The secret lies in a flavorful base enhanced with Dijon mustard and a thoughtful blend of spices, which elevate the simple chicken and mayo combination to something truly special.

The remarkable advancements in egg-free and vegan mayonnaise options have made this recipe not only possible but also exceptionally palatable. I’m confident you could serve this to a gathering of friends and family, and no one would suspect it caters to specific dietary needs. It perfectly captures the nostalgic taste and satisfying texture of a traditional chicken salad, offering a delightful experience for all. My deepest hope is that this gluten, dairy, and egg-free chicken salad sandwich allows you to savor this classic comfort food without worry, bringing joy back to your meal times.

Mastering Gluten-Free Chicken Salad Sandwiches

The primary hurdle when crafting a gluten-free chicken salad sandwich is, unsurprisingly, the bread. While the filling itself is typically gluten-free, selecting the right bread or bun is crucial. Beyond the bread, it’s always wise to meticulously check every ingredient label for hidden gluten, as it can sometimes appear in unexpected places. Thankfully, the market now offers an impressive array of high-quality gluten-free alternatives, ensuring you don’t have to miss out on this beloved sandwich.

Here are some excellent gluten-free options to consider for your chicken salad:

Our absolute favorite gluten-free bread, which is also free from the top 8 allergens and vegan, is Little Northern Bakehouse White Wide Slice. This bread boasts a soft texture and generous slice size, perfect for holding a hearty scoop of chicken salad. While it’s readily available on Amazon, I often find it locally at natural grocery stores. They also offer buns, which are a fantastic choice if you prefer a more traditional sandwich experience, though they can sometimes be harder to locate in brick-and-mortar stores.
For those craving a bun, we highly recommend Schar’s Hamburger Buns or their delightful Schar’s Ciabatta Rolls. The ciabatta rolls, in particular, offer a wonderful texture and are featured in the recipe photos. It’s worth noting that Schar products do contain soy, which is important to consider if soy is also an allergen you need to avoid.
If you’re looking to minimize carbs or simply prefer a lighter option, you can easily transform your chicken salad into a refreshing meal by serving it inside crisp lettuce wraps. Large, sturdy leaves like romaine or butter lettuce work beautifully.
Alternatively, enjoy your chicken salad as a savory dip alongside a variety of gluten-free crackers. This is an excellent choice for appetizers or a casual snack.
Another versatile option is to use gluten-free wraps. Brands like Mission Gluten-free Tortillas or BFree wraps provide a flexible and convenient way to enjoy your chicken salad on the go.
Finally, for a complete and wholesome meal, serve your chicken salad over a generous bed of mixed greens, such as spring mix or baby spinach. This transforms the sandwich filling into a delicious and satisfying salad topping, offering a fresh and vibrant way to enjoy the flavors.

Effortlessly Dairy-Free Chicken Salad Sandwiches

While avoiding dairy can often present a significant challenge in many recipes, it’s remarkably simple when it comes to chicken salad sandwiches. In fact, it’s quite rare for traditional chicken salad fillings to contain dairy at all. Occasionally, you might encounter a recipe that incorporates cheese, but this is an exception rather than the norm. As long as your chosen bread or bun is not buttered with dairy butter or made with dairy-containing ingredients, the core components of the chicken salad filling—mayonnaise, cooked chicken, a blend of spices, and textural additions like crunchy vegetables and sunflower seeds—are naturally dairy-free.

This inherent dairy-free nature makes chicken salad an ideal choice for those managing dairy allergies or intolerances. As always, the golden rule of label checking applies to all ingredients, just to ensure there are no hidden dairy derivatives. However, with this recipe, you won’t need to worry about any specific dairy substitutions within the filling itself, as it is naturally crafted to be entirely dairy-free, making your meal preparation much smoother and stress-free.

Choosing the Best Egg-Free Mayo for Your Chicken Salad Sandwich

An egg-free option isn’t necessary for everyone, but for those who need it, the quality of egg-free mayonnaise is paramount. This recipe’s success truly hinges on the remarkable advancements made in egg-free mayo products. As someone quite particular about mayonnaise, I can confidently say that egg-free options have come a long way in terms of taste and texture. My top recommendation is Hellman’s Vegan Mayo (also widely known as Best Foods Vegan Mayo in some regions). I not only use it exclusively for this chicken salad recipe but also for all my everyday mayonnaise needs.

I typically purchase Hellman’s Vegan Mayo at Walmart, and it’s also conveniently available on Amazon. Its creamy consistency and authentic flavor profile make it an outstanding substitute, ensuring your chicken salad maintains that rich, satisfying mouthfeel without any compromise.

For those who need to scrutinize ingredients, here is the list for Hellman’s Vegan Mayo (please note that formulations can change, so always double-check the label at the time of purchase):

Sunflower oil, water, modified food starch (potato, corn), distilled vinegar, less than 2% of: sugar, salt, lemon juice concentrate, sorbic acid and calcium disodium EDTA (used to protect quality), natural flavor, paprika extract (for color).

*Always check the label when you buy it, as ingredient lists can sometimes change after publication.

Is This Chicken Salad Sandwich Truly Allergy-Friendly?

Absolutely! This chicken salad sandwich recipe is designed to be highly allergy-friendly, allowing a wide range of individuals to enjoy this classic comfort food safely. When prepared using the recommended Little Northern Bakehouse bread and Hellman’s Vegan mayo, this recipe naturally becomes free of many common allergens. Specifically, it is free from: wheat, gluten, dairy, egg, soy, peanuts, tree nuts, fish, and shellfish.

This comprehensive approach means that our chicken salad sandwich is effectively free of the top 8 major allergens, making it a safe and inclusive option for many families managing multiple dietary restrictions. The elimination of these common allergens ensures that more people can once again indulge in the delightful experience of a chicken salad sandwich without worry.

However, it is critically important to always read the labels of every single ingredient you use. Manufacturers occasionally alter their product formulations, and what was safe one day might not be the next. Vigilance and thorough label checking are crucial steps to ensure the continued safety of this recipe for those with severe food allergies. For guests with allergies, it’s always best to involve them in checking ingredients or discussing potential cross-contamination to provide maximum assurance.

Selecting the Perfect Chicken for Your Salad Sandwiches

When it comes to the chicken component of your chicken salad, versatility is key! There’s truly no single “wrong” answer, as many types of cooked chicken can work beautifully. Whether you have leftover chicken from a previous meal, opt for the convenience of store-bought rotisserie chicken (hello, Costco!), or prefer to cook chicken thighs or breasts specifically for this recipe, you’re in good hands.

I often find myself using frozen chicken breasts, transforming them into delicious chicken salad as a fantastic way to clear out my freezer. My go-to method for preparing chicken is in the Instant Pot: I simply place the frozen chicken breasts in the pot with about 3/4 cup of water, a pinch of salt, and a dash of pepper. I then set it to high pressure (also known as manual) for 25 minutes, followed by a natural pressure release for 10 minutes. This results in perfectly tender chicken that’s easy to shred. After draining any liquid, the chicken is ready to be incorporated into the salad.

Feel free to use whichever type of chicken you prefer, what fits your schedule, or what you happen to have on hand. The most important thing is that the chicken is fully cooked and then shredded or chopped into bite-sized pieces, ready to absorb all the delicious flavors of the dressing and accompanying ingredients.

Crafting a Nut-Free Chicken Salad Sandwich

Many traditional chicken salad recipes often call for walnuts or other tree nuts to add a desirable crunch. However, for families like mine who manage severe tree nut allergies, this is simply not an option. The good news is that you can still achieve that satisfying textural contrast without any worries about allergens!

Our preferred and highly effective substitute for tree nuts in this recipe is salted (or unsalted, if you prefer) sunflower seeds. These tiny powerhouses deliver an excellent crunch and a subtle nutty flavor that perfectly complements the chicken salad, ensuring a delightful eating experience for everyone. They provide all the texture you crave, making this a truly safe and enjoyable option for those with nut allergies, while still contributing to the overall fantastic mouthfeel of the sandwich.

Achieving That Authentic Deli-Style Chicken Salad Sandwich Experience

The secret to creating an ultimate chicken salad recipe that rivals your favorite deli lies in two key elements: a flavorful and robust base, and an abundance of extra ingredients for diverse texture and crunch. Gone are the days of bland chicken mixed with just plain mayonnaise. This recipe elevates the humble chicken salad to a gourmet level, making your guests wonder if you bought it from a high-end deli or lovingly crafted it at home. By thoughtfully balancing sweet and salty components, we achieve a complex flavor profile that is truly irresistible.

Here’s the winning combination of ingredients that makes this chicken salad stand out:

Shredded Chicken: The foundation of our delicious sandwich, providing a satisfying protein base.
Red Onion: Finely minced, it offers a crisp, slightly pungent bite that brightens the entire mixture.
Celery: Adds essential crunch and a refreshing, earthy note that’s classic in any chicken salad.
Egg-Free/Vegan Mayo: The creamy binder. Use your favorite vegan variety if needed, or regular mayonnaise if eggs are not an issue. This provides the smooth, rich base.
Dijon Mustard: A critical ingredient that adds a sophisticated tang and depth, moving beyond just simple mayo. It gives the dressing a vibrant, complex flavor.
Seasoned Salt: A blend of spices that enhances the overall savory profile of the salad.
Garlic Salt: Provides a subtle garlic aroma and flavor that rounds out the seasonings beautifully.
Black Pepper to Taste: Freshly ground pepper adds a gentle kick and aromatic warmth. (I often skip additional salt here since my sunflower seeds are already salted.)
Shelled Sunflower Seeds: Our allergy-friendly powerhouse for crunch and a slightly nutty flavor, replacing traditional nuts.
Red Seedless Grapes (halved or quartered): These are non-negotiable for that burst of sweetness and juicy texture, perfectly balancing the savory and salty elements.
Red Leaf Lettuce: (Optional, but highly recommended for serving) Provides a fresh, crisp bed for your chicken salad, adding another layer of texture and freshness.

What I particularly love about this recipe is its simplicity and reliance on common kitchen staples. It doesn’t require any fresh herbs that might not always be on hand. With onion and celery almost always present in my fridge, I can whip this up last minute when dinner plans fall through, making it a reliable and delicious go-to meal.

Popular Substitutions for Your Chicken Salad Recipe

While the core recipe delivers incredible flavor and texture, it’s also quite flexible and allows for various substitutions to suit your personal preferences or what you have available. The beauty of chicken salad lies in its adaptability!

For the Sweet Element: In many gluten-free chicken salad recipes, you’ll find people swapping out red grapes for other sweet additions. Sweet apples (like Honeycrisp or Fuji), green grapes, or even dried cranberries are all fantastic options. The main goal is to introduce a touch of sweetness to balance the savory and salty components, so feel free to use your favorite fruit.
For the Onion: While I prefer red onion for its vibrant color and slightly sharper flavor, green onion (scallions) can also be used. Green onions offer a milder, fresher onion taste. Choose whichever color and flavor profile you prefer for your salad.
For the Lettuce: The type of lettuce you use for your sandwich or as a bed for your salad is entirely up to you. Butter lettuce, romaine lettuce, iceberg, or bibb lettuce all work well, each offering a slightly different texture. My kids, for instance, prefer to skip the lettuce altogether, proving its optional nature!
For the Crunch: If you’re looking for an alternative to sunflower seeds, pumpkin seeds (pepitas) are another excellent nut-free option that provides a satisfying crunch and a slightly different earthy flavor.

Don’t hesitate to experiment with these popular substitutions to customize your chicken salad and make it perfectly yours!

Essential Tools for Making This Gluten-Free Chicken Salad

One of the many appealing aspects of this chicken salad recipe is how little specialized equipment it requires. You likely already have everything you need in your kitchen, making it a quick and easy dish to prepare. You’ll only need a few basic tools to get started:

Cutting Board: For safely chopping your chicken, onion, celery, and grapes.
Chef’s Knife: Or any sharp knife you’re comfortable using for precise cutting.
Large Mixing Bowl: Essential for combining all the ingredients thoroughly without spillage.
Large Spoon or Spatula: For easy stirring and mixing of the salad components.
Measuring Cups and Spoons: To accurately measure your mayonnaise, mustard, spices, and other ingredients, ensuring a consistent and delicious result every time.

With these simple tools, you’ll be whipping up a batch of delicious, allergy-friendly chicken salad in no time!

What to Serve Alongside Your Chicken Salad Sandwiches

We often keep our side dishes wonderfully simple, especially with four small children at home. This aligns perfectly with the unfussy nature of the chicken salad itself. Our go-to pairings usually include classic comfort foods and fresh, healthy options. We love serving our chicken salad sandwiches with a side of crispy French fries, tater tots, or crunchy potato chips for that satisfying, salty complement. Alongside, we always include some fresh fruit and raw veggies to add color, nutrition, and another layer of freshness.

This approach highlights another reason why I adore this meal: it requires minimal fuss, preparation, or time, yet delivers maximum flavor and enjoyment. If you’re seeking a more robust, flavorful side or an alternative to a traditional sandwich, you might also enjoy this Italian-inspired salad, which is not only dairy-free but also allergy-friendly and bursting with bold flavors.

Storing Leftover Gluten-Free Chicken Salad

Proper storage is key to enjoying your delicious gluten-free chicken salad for days to come. If you anticipate having leftovers, it’s best practice to store the chicken salad mixture separately from the bread or buns. This prevents the bread from becoming soggy and ensures both components remain fresh.

Transfer the chicken salad mixture to an airtight container and store it in the refrigerator. When stored correctly, it will keep well for up to three days. This makes it an excellent option for meal prepping ahead of time, allowing you to quickly assemble a fresh sandwich or salad whenever hunger strikes.

It’s important to note for food safety, particularly if you’re serving this at an event like a shower or luncheon, that chicken salad should not be left out at room temperature for more than two hours. Beyond this timeframe, bacterial growth can occur, making the salad unsafe to eat. Always keep it chilled until serving and promptly refrigerate any uneaten portions.

Looking for More Gluten-Free Finger Foods?

If you’re planning a party or gathering and want to complement your chicken salad sandwiches with an array of other delicious gluten-free finger foods, you’re in luck! Here are some fantastic allergy-friendly options that are perfect for entertaining:

Turkey Bacon Ranch Wraps
3 Ingredient Dairy Free Ranch Dip
Vegan Queso (nut-free too!)
Dairy-Free French Onion Dip
Asian Quinoa Meatballs
Italian Pulled Pork Sliders
4 Ingredient BBQ Chicken Sliders
Cranberry Salsa Dip
Chicken Salad Sandwiches (of course!)
Gluten, Dairy, and Egg-Free BLTs
Sesame-Free Hummus (recipe found in my cookbook)

Tastiest Egg-Free Chicken Salad Sandwich

Yield:
10 Sandwiches

Prep Time:
15 minutes

Total Time:
15 minutes

If you miss chicken salad sandwiches because you can’t have gluten, dairy or eggs…I have a way you can still enjoy it. AND, it may just be better than you remember. With lots of texture and crunch and more than just plain mayo, this will be your new favorite way to enjoy this classic.

Ingredients

SALAD INGREDIENTS:

2 cups cooked chicken chopped–approx 2 chicken breasts (leftover or rotisserie works great!)
1/4 red onion, minced finely
1 stalk celery chopped
1/3 cup salted sunflower seeds, shelled
1/3 cup red seedless grapes, halved or quartered
Lettuce leaves (optional)
Your favorite gluten free vegan buns or bread (see post above for options)

DRESSING INGREDIENTS:

1/2 cup vegan mayonnaise (or regular if you can have eggs)
1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
1/2 teaspoon seasoned salt
1/2 teaspoon garlic salt
pepper to taste

Instructions

1. Use leftover chicken (instant pot, slow cooker, grilled, rotisserie–you name it, just about 2 chicken breasts worth) and shred it and add it to a large bowl.

2. Add the rest of your salad ingredients to the bowl.

3. In a small bowl, combine all of your dressing ingredients.

4. Add your dressing ingredients to your salad ingredients and stir to combine. Taste and adjust salt and pepper to your liking. (I find I only need to add pepper, not salt because of the salted sunflower seeds).

5. Toast your buns or bread. Place enough of the completed salad mixture on top of one side of the bread. Place a lettuce leaf on top (optional–my kids just pull it off, hence why it’s not in my photos) and then place to two pieces of bread together.

6. Serve immediately. Keep the salad mixture separate from the bread\/buns if storing leftovers. Keep leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge 2-3 days (great for making ahead of time too!).

Notes

This salad is quite forgiving, so feel free to adjust the ingredients. If you like more crunch, add more celery or sunflower seeds. If you like it more creamy, add a little more mayo. It’s very flexible, so feel free to use the measurements as a guide, rather than a fixed amount.

If you’re looking for some other gluten, dairy and egg free dinners, check out my cookbook: An Allergy Mom’s Lifesaving Instant Pot Cookbook.

*Our allergies, while severe and that get re-tested yearly, are such that we can go strictly by what’s on the label. I do not call companies to see what things are derived from, or call manufacturers to see about potential cross contact. If your allergies require you to do so, please do your own homework. I cannot assure you of any ingredient’s safety, only you can do that. I simply share what works for our family

**If you are going to feed this to someone with food allergies, and you yourself do not have food allergies, I HIGHLY recommend having them check every single brand and ingredient you are using, to ensure they’re OK with each part of the recipe. And, to make sure you’ve talked to them about how to avoid cross contamination in your kitchen.

DON’T FORGET TO PIN THIS RECIPE, SO YOU DON’T LOSE IT! BE SURE WHILE YOU’RE THERE TO CHECK OUT MY OTHER DIETARY SPECIFIC PINTEREST BOARDS FOR MORE ALLERGY-FRIENDLY INSPIRATION.